What is expected from you?
You are supposed to give a presentation (in english) lasting 60 minutes, and
to deliver a manuscript (in english) before your presentation.
The presentation builds on the literature which you are given. You
should present and discuss at least the main results from these
publications. You can decide to make a selection from the material if you
think it is appropriate. You can include material from other related
publications if you think this is good. When in doubt, discuss it with me.
The manuscript (approx. 10 pages) should be typeset using
LATEX and should present the same
material as the talk.
A very good seminar talk...
-
...is well-structured.
-
...shows that you have mastered the material.
-
...shows that you have a firm background knowledge on your topic.
-
...is (mostly) accessible to all participants.
-
...uses well-prepared media (slides).
-
...lasts exactly 60 minutes.
-
...has a good balance between technical details, examples, and general discussions.
A very good manuscript...
-
...is well-structured.
-
...shows that you have mastered the material.
-
...shows that you have a firm background knowledge on your topic.
-
...is self-contained (assuming some reasonable background knowledge).
-
...contains a short abstract, introduction, discussion, and references.
-
...looks nice and uses correct and good english.
-
...is of reasonable length.
-
...has a good balance between technical details, examples, and general discussions.
Improving your presentation and manuscript
-
Start early with your preparations: Literature search takes time (especially
if you need to use interlibrary loan). Learning
LATEX takes time. Understanding the
literature takes time. Typesetting takes (quite a lot of) time. Making an
appointment with me may take time. Unexpected things may happen.
-
Ask other students for their opinions. In particular, I strongly
recommend that you give a test presentation for a few friends. A good and
constructive feedback helps very much to improve a presentation. (I still
use this myself sometimes before important talks.) I also think it is the
only way to get the timing right unless you have much experience with
presentations. I also recommend that you give your manuscript to a friend
for proof-reading.
-
A good preparation is flexible: There may be interruptions during the talk,
e.g. people may ask questions. Or you may be a bit nervous and talk much
faster than you wanted. In either case, you should be prepared to change your
presentation on the spot, by either skipping something, or by including
more. If this is well-done, then the audience will barely notice it.
-
Preparing slides is a very delicate task and should not be
underestimated. Ask others for their opinions. Look at sets of slides which
you may find on the internet - and be aware that many of them are of poor
quality.
-
I suggest that you contact me at least once, namely when you have read
the literature, and have a detailed suggestion for the selection which you
want to present; before actually preparing the talk. Also, contact me
whenever you are in doubt about anything, or just want my opinion about
it.
Back to my home page. Back to the seminar page.